In a recent letter, Ripple offered a harsh rebuke to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) move to block documents crucial to the case.
The U.S SEC vs Ripple lawsuit is still revolving around the revelation and verdict of former director Bill Hinman’s Infamous Ethereum Speech. In the last few sittings, the court has even revised the summary judgment Schedule to draw a conclusion about the case. Meanwhile, Ripple Defendants have filed an opposition to the commission’s claim over the Speech and notes.
The court has directed the commission to display the disputed memos related to the 2018 speech. The SEC has been hesitant to produce them. At first, they even try to shield it under the deliberative process privilege (DPP). Lately, the commission is trying to claim that the memos now come under the Attorney Client Privilege.
Ripple cites four reasons why what the SEC did is wrong:
1) As per the case recordings Hinman gave the speech in his personal capacity. He took advice from the SEC’s staff to prepare the speech. According to the second circuit law, the discussed legal concepts among them don’t fill in for Attorney client privilege.
2) Hinman has the authorisation to receive legal advice and communicated with SEC lawyers. However, the content of his personal remark does not come under the scope of attorney client relationship.
Recommended Articles
3) The discussion over the issue does not involve any confidential information concerning the agency which should be protected under the same privilege.
4) However, the commission completely fails to establish the claim as the privilege belongs to Hinman.
Let the court decide
The defendants have demanded that the SEC should now produce the DPP redactions or any memos to be withheld under the Attorney client Privilege for an In camera inspection. They even requested the court to review the redaction by themself.
The court should evaluate any attorney-client relationship between Hinman and the SEC staff regarding the speech draft. If there is any, then the court decides to include them as legal advice or confidential information shielded by the privilege.
- Mercado Libre Reports $29M in Bitcoin Holdings in SEC Filing
- This Firm Invests $75M In BlackRock, Fidelity, Bitwise, GBTC Bitcoin ETF: SEC Filing
- Jack Dorsey Pledges $21 Million for Bitcoin Development
- Bitcoin Price Breaks $64000 As BTC Bounces off Short-term Average
- Solana Price Jumps As Whale Heavily Bags SOL
- Uniswap Price Analysis: $UNI Eyes $10 Amid Double Bottom Reversal
- Dogecoin Price Prediction: Is $0.2 a Realistic Target in May 2024?
- SHIB Price Forecast: Can Rising Burn Rate Boost Value to $0.0001 Soon?
- Solana Price Prediction: Can SOL Hit $200 By End of May with Strong Market Recovery?
- 6 Top Crypto To Buy As The Altcoin Season Beckons In May